There is no single federal consumer manual that approves every fixed indexed annuity before it is sold. For many of these contracts the day-to-day regulator is the state insurance department. That sentence has a boundary. Whether a particular contract is a security depends on its terms. If it is a security, federal securities law and FINRA rules can apply as well. The SEC’s July 31, 2020 investor bulletin is the place to start on that boundary. This page does not try to restate the conditions in the Dodd-Frank Act for when an annuity is outside the securities laws. Those conditions are statutory text this site is not going to paraphrase from memory.

State insurance departments

Insurers are licensed by states. A fixed indexed annuity that is not a security is sold under state insurance law. The department reviews forms, at least in the way that state’s law requires, and it handles consumer complaints about licensed companies and producers. The address and the complaint process are on your state department’s website, not on this one. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners writes model laws and a buyer’s guide. A model is not the law until a state adopts it, and states edit models. When this site cites Model 805 or Model 275, it is citing the NAIC text and then telling you that your state might differ.

Model 805 is the standard nonforfeiture law for individual deferred annuities. The fall 2020 version of the formula can produce a floor as low as 0.15 percent before an additional reduction tied to an equity-index benefit. FINRA’s 2022 article described a usual guaranteed rate of 1 percent to 3 percent on at least 87.5 percent of premium. Both statements can be true in different senses: one is a model formula a state may have adopted, the other is a regulator’s description of what was usual. Neither is a promise that your index credit will be in that range. Nonforfeiture is a minimum-value rule. The index formula is a separate paragraph in the contract.

Suitability and “best interest” are not a fiduciary duty

In 2020 the NAIC revised the Suitability in Annuity Transactions Model Regulation, Model 275, to use a best-interest standard of care for annuity recommendations. An NAIC brief reports that, as of August 8, 2025, 49 jurisdictions had implemented those revisions. New York is not on that list. New York has its own Regulation 187. If you live in New York, ask about Regulation 187 rather than assuming the NAIC count includes you. If you live elsewhere, the brief’s list is a snapshot of implementations, not a description of every sentence in your state’s rule.

Where a version of Model 275 is in force, a producer who recommends an annuity has duties the model spells out, including care, disclosure, conflict, and documentation pieces, and the insurer has a supervision duty. That is a regulatory standard. It is not, by itself, a fiduciary relationship. The model says nothing in it should be read to create a private lawsuit for a violation, or to impose liability on the producer as a fiduciary under that best-interest standard. A later provision says the care requirements do not create a fiduciary obligation and only create the regulatory obligation in the model. Do not walk into a sales meeting believing “best interest” means the producer must recommend the cheapest product in the entire market, or that you can sue under the model text alone. Some states change the model’s wording. A private lawyer, not this website, can tell you what your state actually enacted.

The model also does not require the producer to analyze every product outside the producer’s license. A recommendation can meet the rule and still be a product you do not want. The specimen contract remains your document.

When the contract is a security

The SEC bulletin says the SEC regulates indexed annuities that are securities, and that those contracts can expose you to investment losses. Registered index-linked annuities are in that group. They can reduce principal when the index falls, subject to whatever buffer or floor the prospectus describes. They are not the fixed indexed annuity the NAIC guide is talking about when it says a down index typically credits zero if you do not withdraw. If you are offered a security, you should receive a prospectus, and the seller is dealing with securities rules as well as insurance rules. FINRA’s investor materials on annuities cover the securities side of variable annuities and the cautions that overlap.

Guaranty associations are not the regulator

A state guaranty association pays, within limits, if a licensed insurer fails. It does not approve the cap and it does not license the producer. NOLHGA says most associations provide at least $250,000 in present value of annuity benefits and that limits vary. New York’s department describes up to $500,000 for a New York resident’s fixed benefits. That is a New York figure. Coverage is not a reason to choose an insurer or to buy a larger contract. The regulator you can call before there is a failure is the state insurance department.

Free look and advertising

States set free-look periods. The NAIC and FINRA describe the window as often 10 to 30 days, and the refund may be premium or account value depending on the state. Advertising of annuities is also policed under state unfair-trade rules. A violation of an advertising rule, if one occurred, is a complaint to the department. It is not something this site can adjudicate from a brochure you paste into an email.

Taxes are federal, and they are the IRS’s subject, not the insurance department’s. Topic 410, Publication 575, and the Form 5329 instructions are the public sources. Required distributions from traditional IRAs generally start at age 73 on the IRS page. Your insurance regulator does not set that age.

Sources

Not advice. IndexedAnnuity.com is not an insurance company, agency, broker-dealer, or tax advisor. Nothing here is a recommendation to buy, hold, or replace a contract. Guarantees exist only in a specific contract and depend on the insurer’s ability to pay. Products and state laws differ. Read the contract.
Affiliate disclosure: This site may earn a commission if you buy books through Amazon links. It does not currently recommend specific contracts or insurers.