A fixed indexed annuity can fit a narrow job and still carry risks that the sales conversation skips. The risks below are the ones regulators describe. They do not include a forecast of returns, because this site does not have one and will not invent one.

You can receive less than you paid

The SEC says you can lose money on an indexed annuity if you cancel early, because a surrender charge can exceed the interest you have been credited. FINRA says the same: you may get back less than the premium. The period is often six to ten years or longer, and it can restart if you replace the contract. A market-value adjustment, which is not on every contract, can reduce the value further when rates have moved. A withdrawal during a term can forfeit index interest that has not been credited yet, which is the NAIC guide’s warning. “Credited interest is locked” does not protect interest that is not credited.

There is a second way people lose relative to what they expected, without a surrender. The cap, the participation rate, the spread, and the exclusion of dividends can leave the credit far below a stock-market headline. That is not a loss of principal in a year the formula credits zero or a small positive number. It is an opportunity cost. The SEC’s hypotheticals are how to measure it in a single year: a 12 percent index change against a 7 percent cap credits 7 percent in the illustration, not 12. Over many years that gap can be large. It can also be the price of the zero-percent treatment in down years. You do not get to claim the protection and the uncapped index.

The insurer can fail

Every promise in the contract is a promise of the insurance company. FINRA states that annuities are not FDIC insured and not SIPC insured. FDIC insurance is for deposits at insured banks, generally $250,000 per depositor, per bank, per ownership category, including CDs. It does not follow your money into an annuity.

If an insurer becomes insolvent, a state life and health insurance guaranty association may provide coverage. NOLHGA says most associations provide at least $250,000 in present value of annuity benefits and that the limits vary by state. The New York Department of Financial Services describes protection up to $500,000 for a New York resident’s fixed annuity benefits. That figure is New York’s. It is not a national minimum and not a target size for a purchase. Guaranty coverage is not a reason to buy a contract, and it is not a target for how much to put with one insurer. Read the regulation page for how supervision works before a failure, which is a different topic from the guaranty association after a failure.

The formula can change at renewal

FINRA wrote that the insurer may change caps, participation rates, and spreads in later terms. A renewal can be within a low contractual guarantee and still be disappointing next to the illustration you were shown. There is no public “average cap” that tells you the renewal will be fine. The risk is that you are then inside a surrender period with a less useful formula. That is a reason to read the guaranteed minimum limiter, not a reason to assume the current limiter is the guaranteed one.

Inflation and a long series of small credits

A contract that credits zero in several terms, or that credits a small positive minimum, can leave the purchasing power of the account lower. Nothing in the indexed design promises an inflation adjustment. A declared-rate annuity and a CD have their own versions of this risk. It is still a risk here, and it is easy to ignore because the sales story emphasizes the years the index was up.

Taxes can take a slice you did not model

Earnings are tax-deferred, not tax-free. Withdrawals of gain are generally ordinary income. From a nonqualified contract, amounts not taken as an annuity are generally income first. Before age 59½, an additional 10 percent tax may apply to the taxable part unless an exception applies. Putting the contract inside a traditional IRA does not remove required distributions, which generally begin at 73, and does not usually add deferral. A botched 1035 — one where you receive the check — is a taxable distribution under Revenue Ruling 2007-24, possibly on top of a surrender charge.

The wrong product

Registered index-linked annuities can lose principal. They are securities. A buffer is not the same thing as the typical fixed indexed zero credit. If you buy a RILA thinking it works like the NAIC guide’s description of an indexed fixed annuity, the risk is a market loss you did not agree to in your own mind, even if the prospectus disclosed it. Read the page that says whether negative index performance reduces the account.

Complexity is its own risk. Bonuses, income bases, and participation rates can be described with a confidence the contract does not support. The defense is dull: the specimen contract, the renewal guarantee, the surrender table, and a tax advisor who is not paid to sell the annuity.

Sources

Not advice. IndexedAnnuity.com is not an insurance company, agency, broker-dealer, or tax advisor. Nothing here is a recommendation to buy, hold, or replace a contract. Guarantees exist only in a specific contract and depend on the insurer’s ability to pay. Products and state laws differ. Read the contract.
Affiliate disclosure: This site may earn a commission if you buy books through Amazon links. It does not currently recommend specific contracts or insurers.